Vote: Best Pizza in Valrico — Community Poll

We asked a simple question on social media: what's the best pizza in Valrico? The responses came fast, and people had opinions. Here's where things stand after 847 votes — and you can still weigh in.

The Results So Far

1. Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza — 42% (356 votes)
2. Jet's Pizza — 18% (153 votes)
3. Hungry Howie's — 15% (127 votes)
4. Other — 13% (110 votes)
5. Pizza Hut — 12% (101 votes)

Not even close. Eddie & Sam's ran away with it. But the "Other" category had some interesting write-ins — keep reading.

Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza — The Runaway Winner

Address: 1016 E Brandon Blvd, Brandon, FL 33511

If you've lived in the Valrico-Brandon area for more than a year, you've probably been told to go here at least three times. Eddie & Sam's has been the go-to for New York-style slices since they opened. The crust is thin, foldable, and has that char on the bottom that chain places can't replicate.

Locals rave about the Grandma slice, the white pizza, and the garlic knots. It's a no-frills spot — you're not going for the ambiance. You're going because the pizza is legitimately great.

What voters said: "Not even a competition." "Best pizza between here and actual New York." "The Grandma slice is life-changing."

Jet's Pizza — The Detroit-Style Contender

Address: 3646 Lithia Pinecrest Rd, Valrico, FL 33596

Jet's brought Detroit-style deep dish to Valrico and carved out a loyal following. The signature is the crispy, cheesy edge crust — caramelized cheese baked directly against the pan. Their 8 Corner Pizza is engineered so every slice is a corner slice.

If you're a thin-crust purist, Jet's probably won't convert you. But for people who want a thick, cheesy, indulgent pizza night, this is the spot.

What voters said: "The turbo crust is addictive." "Best deep dish outside of Detroit or Chicago." "My kids would eat here every night if I let them."

Hungry Howie's — The Flavored Crust Favorite

Address: 3536 Lithia Pinecrest Rd, Valrico, FL 33596

Hungry Howie's isn't trying to be artisan pizza. It's solid, reliable, and the flavored crusts give it a hook that keeps people coming back. Butter cheese, Cajun, ranch — there's a crust flavor for every mood.

The calzones and Howie Bread are sleeper hits. For a quick weeknight dinner that doesn't break the bank, Hungry Howie's delivers (literally and figuratively).

What voters said: "Butter cheese crust forever." "Best value for a family pizza night." "Underrated — better than people give it credit for."

Pizza Hut — Still in the Game

Address: 904 E Bloomingdale Ave, Brandon, FL 33511

Look, Pizza Hut isn't going to win any foodie awards. But 12% of voters picked it, and that says something. The pan pizza hits a nostalgia note for a lot of people, and the lunch buffet (when available) is still one of the best deals around.

What voters said: "Book It personal pan pizza shaped my childhood." "The stuffed crust is still good, I don't care what anyone says."

The "Other" Write-Ins

The 13% who voted "Other" had some strong opinions:

• Pepo's Cuban Cafe — technically Cuban food, but their Cuban pizza got multiple mentions
• Little Caesars — the "I'm not pretending to be fancy" crowd showed up strong
• Domino's — a few loyalists held the line
• Costco pizza — we respect the honesty

Cast Your Vote

Think we got it wrong? Have a favorite we missed? Vote in the poll on our homepage or drop a comment below. We'll update the results at the end of April.

---

FAQ

What is the best pizza place in Valrico?

Based on our community poll of 847 Valrico residents, Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza is the clear favorite with 42% of the vote. It's known for authentic New York-style thin crust, Grandma slices, and garlic knots.

Where can I get deep dish pizza in Valrico?

Jet's Pizza at 3646 Lithia Pinecrest Rd in Valrico serves Detroit-style deep dish with their signature crispy cheese edge crust. They came in second in our community poll with 18% of the vote.

Is there good New York-style pizza near Valrico?

Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza on East Brandon Blvd is widely considered the best New York-style pizza in the Valrico-Brandon area. Locals describe the crust as thin, foldable, and properly charred — the closest thing to actual NYC pizza in the area.