What are the best middle schools in Valrico?

Randall Middle School is the top-performing middle school serving the Valrico area, with 84% math proficiency and a 5-star SchoolDigger rating. Mulrennan Middle School is the other primary option, ranking in the top 20% of Florida middle schools.

Middle school is where school zones start to really drive real estate decisions. Here's how the options break down.

1. Randall Middle School

Niche Grade: A | SchoolDigger: 5 stars | Ranked #118 in Florida

Randall Middle is located in the FishHawk community on Fishhawk Boulevard and serves students from the southern Valrico and Lithia areas. This is the clear top performer.

• Math proficiency: 84%
• Reading proficiency: 75%
• Algebra 1 EOC proficiency: 98% (vs. 59% district average)
• Student-teacher ratio: 22:1
• Enrollment: ~1,100 students

Those Algebra 1 numbers are staggering — 98% proficiency when the county average is 59%. Randall consistently ranks in the top 10% of Florida middle schools.

Neighborhoods zoned here: FishHawk Ranch, parts of southern Valrico, Alafia area, Lithia

2. Mulrennan Middle School

Niche Grade: B+ | SchoolDigger: 3 stars | Ranked #16 in Tampa Area (Niche)

Mulrennan serves the core of Valrico and is the middle school most Valrico families are zoned for. It's a solid school that outperforms county averages across the board.

• Math proficiency: 59% (vs. 55% county average)
• Reading proficiency: 57% (vs. 52% county average)
• Algebra 1 EOC proficiency: 84% (vs. 59% district average)
• Student-teacher ratio: 22:1
• Enrollment: ~1,166 students

Mulrennan is a large school with a wide zone. Performance is above average, though there's a noticeable gap between Mulrennan and Randall. The school offers a range of electives including band, chorus, and STEM programs.

Neighborhoods zoned here: Central Valrico, Bloomingdale, Diamond Hill, Buckhorn area

3. Burns Middle School

GreatSchools: 5/10 | Serves northern Valrico/Brandon border

Burns Middle serves some of the neighborhoods on the northern edge of Valrico that border Brandon. It's an average school that doesn't rank as high as Randall or Mulrennan but still provides a solid foundation.

Neighborhoods zoned here: Northern Valrico, parts of Brandon near the Valrico border

How Valrico middle schools compare

| School | Math Proficiency | Reading Proficiency | Niche Grade | |---|---|---|---| | Randall | 84% | 75% | A | | Mulrennan | 59% | 57% | B+ | | Burns | ~50% | ~50% | B | | Hillsborough County avg | 55% | 52% | — |

All three Valrico-area middle schools perform at or above the county average, but Randall is in a different league entirely.

The middle school gap matters for high school

Here's something parents don't always think about: middle school performance directly impacts high school readiness. Students from Randall tend to enter Newsome High School with stronger foundational skills, which contributes to Newsome's high test scores and graduation rate.

If you're making a school-zone-driven home purchase and your kids are headed into middle school, this is a critical factor. The difference between a Randall-to-Newsome pipeline and other combinations is significant.

School choice and magnet options

If you're not zoned for your preferred middle school, Hillsborough County does offer school choice transfers. However, these are competitive — popular schools like Randall fill up fast, and approval isn't guaranteed. Magnet programs at other Hillsborough County middle schools (like Williams and Ferrell) are also options, though they require applications and transportation.

FAQ

Does Randall Middle School have a gifted program?

Yes. Randall offers gifted services and advanced coursework. The FishHawk community's high parental involvement and academic expectations contribute to a culture that supports advanced learners.

Is Mulrennan Middle School a good school?

Yes. Mulrennan consistently outperforms the Hillsborough County average in both math and reading. It's a solid, above-average middle school. It's not Randall, but it's a school that serves its students well and has active parent engagement.

What middle school zone should I prioritize when buying a home?

If middle school rankings are your top priority and budget allows, the Randall Middle zone (FishHawk/southern Valrico) is the strongest option. Mulrennan's zone covers more of central Valrico and offers a good balance of school quality and home value.

---

Barrett Henry is a REALTOR and Broker Associate with RE/MAX Collective, helping families navigate school zones and home purchases in Valrico for 23+ years.

Want to find a home in a specific middle school zone? I verify zone assignments on every transaction. Call or text (813) 733-7907 or visit nowtb.com.